Interview with APIL: what is current immigrant situation in South Korea?
Updated: Dec 28, 2022
Sejin Kim, an attorney for the organization APIL ‘어필’, in order to protect the human rights of foreigners and immigrants in South Korea, agreed to answer my questions for an interview. She wishes to raise awareness about the available legal protections every migrant in South Korea can access. The organization she is part of, ‘Advocacy for Public Interest Law’, is committed to protecting five causes: refugees and migrants, unhuman traffic, foreigners detained for an unlimited period, stateless people, and the victims of transnational Korean companies.

Source: APIL website
Q- How was this association created? How the decision to make a non-profit organization to help migrants was taken? How long did it take? Was it hard to hire other lawyers?
A- [Sejin Kim] APIL was created in 2011 by 김종철 [Kim Jong Chul]. He is an attorney who used to handle many refugee applications even before creating APIL. He is fascinated by the courageous and dramatic life stories of immigrants and begins working with them for this reason. “I think that by helping a person live a better story, I can buy a better story myself”. In 2018, he proves his interest and enthusiasm by receiving the ‘Hero award for Combat Human Trafficking from the US secretary of State Mike Pompeo.


Source: APIL website Source: APIL website
To establish APIL, he was able to ask for help from his friends to provide funding. However, it took him around four to five years to have this standing of a ‘non-profit organization’. It was also very difficult to hire lawyers at the time, such as now: APIL does not have a lot of lawyers at the moment.
Q- In 2019 and 2020, South Korea’s asylum seeker acceptance rate was 0.4%. Nowadays it is still very low (around 1%). According to you, why this acceptance rate became low in 2019? Is there any event that could explain the situation?
A- [Sejin Kim] To answer this, I need to tell you some about Korean history. South Korea started to ratify the refugee convention in 1992 and started to apply it in 1994. Back then, the acceptance rate was higher than it is now. Nowadays, only a few applications are made.
However, the issue of the refugee has taken on greater importance: it started to be a public policy issue. To remedy the situation, a refugee law has been legislated in 2013. From that moment on, South Korea has been divided into two sides: pro-refugee side VS. anti-refugee side.
From the perspective of the immigration office which controls overseas, refugees and immigration in South Korea, they have not been really supportive of the pro-refugee side. The immigration office is the one who adjudicates refugees’ claims and applications but yet they do not really care about protecting their human rights and only see refugees as ‘subject of control’.
For instance, did you hear about Syrian refugees in Incheon Airport?
In 2015, refugees from Syria have been controlled by the immigration office at the moment of their entrance into South Korea’s territory, at Incheon Airport. Back then, that event coincided with the terrorist attacks in Paris and because of that, Korean media ‘somehow’ connected that event with refugees in general. The consequences are obvious, they made the “anti-refugee” sentiment grows. Hate against refugees among the population began to expand more and more.
Another example would be the case of Yemen’s refugees in 2018. The “anti-refugee” sentiment among Koreans increased again. Previously it was only online but after 2018, it became an offline situation.
Also, the government is influenced by the population because since then, the government is having more hesitations to accept refugee statute requests: indeed, the government is afraid of a global movement.
Q- From an international point of view, do you think South Korea’s acceptance rate is lower than other countries in Asia or other continents?
A- [Sejin Kim] “It’s hard to say what is factual so let me add some assumptions”.
The immigration office thinks that there are a lot of “fake refugees” in South Korea. It means people applying for refugee status based on merit instead of refugees’ usual claims.
While their history is rather short in South Korea, this negative perspective or sentiment towards refugees got ‘in a way’ imported into the country from other parts of the world, like Europe for instance.
At first, Europe had sympathy toward refugees. Later on, refugees got exploited or used for political purposes and that caused ‘anti-refugee’ sentiment in Europe.
As for South Korea, we did not have that initial stage where we originally had sympathy towards refugees. We did not have proper bases on who they are and what are their rights.
Moreover, there is a certain nationalist school of thought that some Koreans joined, known as ‘민족’ [Minjok]. They like to think that Korean nationality / ethnic group is singular. So of course, they tend to exclude immigrants.
In my opinion, the situation can be worsened by the so-called “damages or harms” refugees cause to South Korea. There is a misconception according to which, Korean government gives a lot of money to refugees as initial aid for their adjustment and living costs. That is false because those immigrants are people from North Korea who just escaped. And according to Korean law and system, north Korean are not considered as refugees. They benefit from a special status: once they enter South Korea, they are automatically considered as South Korean nationals citizens and not as refugees. Therefore, real refugees do not benefit from this aid from the state.
There is also this famous idea according to which, immigrants are stealing jobs from Koreans. This idea is false because refugees always tense to work in workplaces or industries Koreans usually avoid: unoccupied jobs.
To conclude, it is difficult to say whether South Korea’s situation is worse than other countries since this “anti-refugees” sentiment is shared by many other countries.
Q- To remain in the subject of international law, South Korea did not sign the Universal Declaration of Human Rights or the Charter of the UN despite its role in the international organization, such as any other international treaty related to the protection of refugees from what I know. So, my question is, which text shall protect them on a trial?
A- [Sejin Kim] In terms of international laws on refugees or migrants, South Korea signed the international refugee law in 1992 in addition to its refugee legislation in 2013.
Moreover, according to some Constitutional Court of South Korea’s precedents, the state ‘s Constitution can be applied to foreigners as well even if only South Korean citizens are mentioned. Hence, the Constitution is applied by extension for all matters related to immigration, education, health, refugees’ treatment conditions…
However, those laws are still not enough or not as efficient as we want them to be.
Q- On your website, you refer to an action of “ensuring that barriers of the system disappear one by one”. What are those barriers about which you are talking? How can you make them disappear? What is your impact on the decisions of lawmakers and the government of South Korea?
A- [Sejin Kim] To destroy those barriers, we are using the precedent in former lawsuits and then, changing the policy itself. We also closely communicate with the department of the government that handles refugee policies. If for example, we want to amend a law, it is quite difficult because we need to organize for our goals to match with their goals and thus, to persuade the Congress representatives.
Communication was not always easy, but we did always reach an agreement until now.
Q- About the stateless people that you mention on your website as one of your five actions. Let us take the example of children of migrants that are born in South Korea. In this country, to have the nationality, only the right of blood prevails. It means one of your parents needs to be Korean himself for you to have Korean nationality. There is no right of soil/ground: being born in South Korea does not give you Korean nationality. Therefore, those children do not have any certificate of birth and as result, it is very difficult to obtain any other documents or to access education or health in South Korea.
To remedy this situation, you introduce a “universal birth declaration system” (UBDS) to the congress and government. It would allow every child in South Korea to report their birth and then obtain a birth certificate and the rights that come with it. Is it going to be voted on soon by the parliament? How could this theoretically work?
A- [Sejin Kim] The Department of Education has been supportive of the UBDS but unfortunately, there has been no draft or speculation yet. Nevertheless, we know the direction is going toward that universal system even if we do not know how it could be applied in real life.
Q- Can you tell me more about the advocacy for the rights of foreigners who have been unfairly detained for an undetermined period?
A- [Sejin Kim] In terms of immigration detention in South Korea, there are two systems.
Either migrants already entered south Korea’s territory which means they got out of Incheon Airport, then they can be detained in the immigration detention center. For the refugees to be released we found a way to cancel the order by immigration
to detain the migrants. We wrote a petititon for the attention of the UN: they did answer for one case and write back an injunction so that person could be released.
The Detention of foreigners in South Korea is based on Article 63 of Korean Immigration Law. According to this article, the detention of foreigners is unlimited in time: indeed, it does not have a maximum period limit. It can be undefined as long as the person does not leave the country of his own will.
APIL tried to persuade the government to amend that article alas it was not willing to do so. Instead, APIL recently open a lawsuit at the Constitutional Court to evaluate whether this law is constitutional or not. We are still waiting for the decision.
If article 63 is determined unconstitutional, we will meet with congress representatives, and prepare an amendment on immigration law and how to amend this article on undefined detention.
We also created a petition for that purpose to make the population aware of this issue.
Either migrants did not enter South Korean territory yet: they are still at the border. Then they would be detained at the airport. Let us take again the Syrian case as an example. APIL was able to argue that it was arbitrary detention because technically, there are no legal bases for it. So, the lawsuit was not to convince the immigration to release that detention but to cancel the non-acceptance of the refugee applications. In the end, the Immigration office finally accepted it, and the refugees were able to enter the territory. De facto the detention was released.
In the process, we also thought about making a petition to the UN on arbitrary detention but unfortunately, we were not able to get much aid from them for that case.
Q- On the issue of sexual or labor exploitation or traffic. You mention on your website the example of migrants exploited on a boat as a labor force for six months to one year, without any access to their passport and the prohibition to touch the ground of any country. You took action against this issue, please tell me more about it.
A- [Sejin Kim] For human traffic, it is not really APIL specialization but other colleagues ‘. So, we are unable to provide very detailed explanations.
However, we can tell you that it is possible to raise a lawsuit for unhuman trafficking in front of a criminal court: Korean law punishes it. Also, APIL collaborates with the victims to provide legal assistance and to legislate. Nevertheless, we notice that there are no articles or clauses that could provide an efficient punishment against human trafficking.
For the boat example, what we can do is send a petition to the attention of the Ministry of Oceans to raise awareness among migrants in South Korea or willing to live here.
Q- To finish on a brighter note, what is the proudest achievement APIL did?
A- [Sejin Kim] First, it would be the refugee law of 2013 because the founder of APIL, 김종철, contributes a lot to the making of that law.
Secondly, APIL is the only attorney organization that is specialized in refugee law. Thanks to us, a lot of precedents where we won the trial exists. That would be the greatest achievement for me.
If you want to know more about APIL, check their website.

Comments