top of page
fuck.png

Neanderthals: a testimony to ancestral altruism

Amandine Venot
Aug 10, 2024
4 min read

Neanderthal society has long been perceived as primitive and inferior to modern humans, Homo sapiens. However, recent archaeological researches have revealed the existence of complex social lives and more advances cognitive abilities among our ancestors. In Spain, the recent discovery of a young child diagnosed with Down syndrome is believed to be the first evidence of selfless empathy in Neanderthal society. This case raises numerous questions within the scientific community.


By Amandine Venot





During the exploration of Cova Negra, in Valencia, Spain, Neanderthal remains were uncovered. By studying the fossils, Spanish researchers from the University of Alcala identified an individual (CN-46700) with Down syndrome who had reached the age of six. This fact is challenging to imagine for the scientific community without the support of his social group.


Down Syndrome: A Controversial Diagnosis


“We do not know of any prehistoric human with the same pathology who lived for more than 16 months!” exclaims Romain David, researcher at the Natural History Museum in London and author of Morphology and Function of the Ear Ossicles in Neanderthals and Modern Humans.


The young individual lived an exceptionally long life for someone with symptoms that, according to researchers, likely included near-total hearing loss and fragile balance. Down syndrome, also known as trisomy 21, is a severe genetic condition. Affected individuals typically exhibit altered facial features, as well as delayed physical and mental development.


This condition was identified on the neanderthal child through five morphological distinctions detected in the individual’s inner ear. These include malformations of the lateral and anterior semicircular canals, a reduced size of the cochlea and vestibule, as well as a highly dilated vestibular aqueduct. Mercedes Conde Valverde, one of the researchers who conducted the study on the Cova Negra (CN-46700), explains that “these syndromes only occur together in individuals with Down syndrome”.


Romain David, however, questions the diagnosis made by Spanish researchers, considering it “ a bit too speculative”. According to him, it has not been definitely proven that the individual actually had this condition. He analyzed the study’s results for National Geographic. His conclusions are to say the least, surprising.


Among the five morphological indicators, Dr. David sees only one that may be significant: semicircular canal dysplasia.


“As far as I know, it is not, by itself, a marker of Down syndrome", he asserts.

The semicircular canal, a bone located beneath the temples, is essential for controlling balance by detecting head movements. In the Neanderthal child, it is malformed. However, to confirm a balance and hearing defect, the semicircular canal malformation must affect both ears. However, in this case, the research was conducted on only one auditory organ, as the second ear was not found. “Therefore, it is difficult to draw conclusions”, says Dr. David.


The researcher also point out that individuals suffering from balance disorders and lateral canal dysplasia do not have a central bony island. “This specimen retained its bony island” he confirms. So, if this Neanderthal child did not have Down syndrome, what condition might he have had?


Romain David notes the possible existence of an “acute otitis media that may have been complicated by labyrinthitis”. Labyrinthitis is an infection or inflammation of the inner ear’s labyrinth, a structure crucial for balance and hearing. The young Neanderthal likely experienced issues such as imbalance hearing loss, tinnitus, and dizziness, which could have even led to nausea and vomiting.


For Romain David, whether the Neanderthal child was already suffering from these symptoms before this point is “debatable”. The condition would not be congenital. However, the hypothesis that the child died as a result of contracting this illness is “more than plausible”. Dr. David remains “skeptical” of the diagnosis established by the Spanish researchers but does not exclude the possibility that it could be correct.


The only way to be certain would have been to obtain a DNA sample, which is, according to him, “the greatest difficulty”. He explains “morphological markers can also indicate other diseases or conditions, or simply bone degradation that did not fossilize properly”.


The first evidence of altruistic empathy in our ancestors


The discovery of CN-46700 remains a puzzling new perspective on the medical care provided by the Neanderthal community. According to Mercedes Conde Valverde, the fact that an individual with such a debilitating condition -regardless of its nature- survived to the age of six “implies that the rest of the group cared for him”. His case is already extraordinary when compared to other instances of Neanderthal adults who also had disabilities. These Neanderthals did not grow up with their conditions but acquired them later in life. They too survived due to the medical care provided  by their social group.


However, the difference here, according to researcher Conde Valverde, is that “it is not a case of completely selfless empathy but rather reciprocal altruism”. Assistance was indeed provided, but with the expectation of reciprocation. Can a six-year-old child, who is also disabled, fulfill such a requirement?


“Obviously not”, asserts the researcher. “The case of the Cova Negra fossil is different. We believe that the parents alone would not have been sufficient for the child’s survival. The entire group must have helped and integrated him over a long period, without expecting anything in return”. His survival could be the first evidence of what is termed “parental” collaboration among group members. The scientific community largely shares this view.


The discovery of CN-46700 might represent the first evidence of selfless empathy in Neanderthals.

Empathy:  a genetic origin?


“Empathy for vulnerable individuals within a group is something that at first glance, all societies have experienced regardless of culture”, informs Dr. Conde Valverde.


“We believe that such a widespread behavior across all cultures must have a genetic basis and can be passed down from generation to generation”.

This hypothesis was the subject of a study conducted by the Pasteur Institute in collaboration with researchers from the University of Cambridge, Paris Diderot University, the CNRS, and the genetic company 23andMe. The scientists discovered that at least one-tenth of empathetic behavior is associated with genetic factors. They confirm that genes do play a role in empathy among humans. However, they also note that “the variation in empathy levels is also due to socialization and other non-genetic factors”.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page