Russia’s Hidden War: The Struggle for freedom, truth and a Nation’s Future
Updated: Mar 23, 2023
Have you heard of the Ukraine-Russia war? If you have not come across a single article about the situation in Ukraine, then you must be living on Mars! Indeed, numerous press agencies and newspapers have been reporting from the ground. For instance, the media outlet Loopsider recently released a video referencing a tweet from the official account of Ukraine’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. This tweet went viral as it displayed photographs of the city of Marinka in Ukraine, destroyed by Russian bombs. Nothing remains.

These are undoubtedly horrifying images, aimed at urging nations to continue aiding the country devastated by the war. However, we must also remember that Russian citizens are living through a nightmare as well.
Before the war, Putin spoke of Russia as “an oasis of stability, a safe haven”. Since then, we know that things have changed, if not worsened.
What prompted Russia to start this war in the first place?
Aside from the mad desire to conquer territories, one might speculate that Vladimir Putin also sought to conduct a special operation to support his re-election in 2024. With his presidential term nearing its end, Putin needed a victorious event. He already envisioned achieving victory in 2022, showcasing his power, glory, and bravery to Russian citizens in 2023. Consequently, in 2024, Russian citizens would see him as the ultimate presidential candidate, if not the only one.
However, Putin did not foresee the ferocity of Ukraine’s defense. By severely underestimating Ukraine’s resistance and the determination of Western nations to support Kyiv, the cost has proven to be much higher than anticipated. Estimates suggest that tens of thousands of Russian soldiers have lost their lives, with hundreds of thousands of Russian citizens enlisted in the military. Ganna Malia, the Ukrainian Vice Minister of Defense, commented “Russia is sending thousands of its citizens to the slaughterhouse” (source).
In response, we are witnessing a massive exodus of Russian citizens, including many young, qualified, and educated individuals. This brain drain is already impacting the economy. Human Rights Watch reports that two waves of emigration occurred in 2022: one right after February 24th, and another following the announcement of a “general military draft of mobilization or reservists” in September.
What does the Russian population think of the conflict?
It is crucial to remember that surveys in Russia are not conducted with complete freedom due to the extremely repressive context. Citizens are aware that they do not have freedom of expression, as censorship is more than prevalent, and new laws were established at the onset of the war, contributing to a climate of fear.
Official surveys assessing the Russian population’s opinion on the war have produced somewhat paradoxical results. The first survey shows that 60% of respondents would have supported a new offensive in Kyiv. In contrast, the second survey reveals that 65% of respondents would have backed ending conflict and signing a peace treaty. Both surveys have predominantly positive results, even though the questions are opposite.
According to Russians, there is no contradiction here, as they will support whatever decision President Putin makes.
What about the youth who have fled the country?
Surveys show that they are protesting in the streets to express their dissent. A study conducted by the Levada Institute suggests that young people are among the most troubled and disrupted by the war, possibly because their sense of patriotism is weaker (source).
Adding to the existing sentiment of anger, Putin announced a decree on September 21st, 2022, to support mobilization efforts in Ukraine. The decree calls for a partial mobilization of Russian citizens, specifically those with military status or who have served in the Russian armed forces. However, the decree includes limitations, such as age limits for military service or health reasons preventing a person from responding unless they have expressly desired to enlist (source).
The decree was intentionally vague, allowing for greater manipulation depending on the context. This means that anyone could be mobilized at any time, creating an unclear and uncertain situation. To clarify this ambiguity, additional information was published stating that “combat experience” would be the primary criterion for mobilization.
Furthermore, the Defence Minister added that “each region has a distinct mobilization task”. This allows for different treatment between regions based on their wealth level or diverse ethnicities and religious backgrounds, potentially leading to discrimination. However, the Defense Minister clarified that “there is no question of mobilizing university students”.
Many people want to avoid mobilization, but this comes at their own risk:
The State Duma, the lower house of the Federal Assembly of Russia, has amended (modify) the criminal code to stipulate that “failure by a subordinate to comply with the order of the leader (in this case, President Putin) in times of war, armed conflict, or combat operations, as well as refusal to participate in military operations“ is punishable by imprisonment up to three years and “in the event of serious consequences, up to 10 years”.
The penalty can also be extended in the case of desertion: “for desertion during the mobilization period, in times of war or armed conflict”, the penalty is 15 years in prison, and for “evading military service by feigning illness”, the penalty is 10 years.
Additionally, a 1997 law requires citizens registered with the military not to leave their place of residence without authorization from military enlistment offices upon the announcement of mobilization.
Now, let’s focus on what is happening in practice. There is mounting evidence of massive and forced mobilizations, particularly in the eastern provinces causing panic to spread throughout the country.
In this image, we can see a Russian citizen being arrested by law enforcement officers during a protest against Vladimir Putin’s call for mobilization in Moscow, as captured by AFP (source).
But anti-mobilization offenses protesters are not the only ones risking everything. According to the non-governmental organization Human Rights Watch, there have been relentless attacks on civil rights activists, independent journalists, politicians who disagree with the government, and anyone expressing social non-conformism since the beginning of the war. To be more specific, parliament has adopted new laws introducing censorship of the word “war”, which carries a sentence for “offences” when referring to the armed conflict as a war, criticizing the invasion, discussing the decisions of Russian armed forces, or reporting on war crimes committed by Russian military personnel.
Russian state media and communication regulators have warned mainstream media against disseminating false and unverified information”, requesting that they refer to the war only as a “special military operation”.
Between February 28 and March 3, 2022, Russian authorities blocked no fewer than 8 Russian media sites. They have two choices: relocate outside Russia or switch their usual platforms to alternative dissemination platforms such as social networks.
For example, the media outlet Novaya Gazeta, one of the largest independent newspapers had its operations suspended in Russia from February 28th after communications regulators (Roskomnadzor – RKN) got involved. In the meantime, the renowned newspaper launched an online platform, but it too was blocked within weeks for “discrediting and false information”. Novaya Gazeta was fined 650,000 rubles, which is over $10 000 US or over 8000€, for claiming a violation of media freedoms. Furthermore, in early September, a Russian court revoked Novaya Gazetta’s printing license.
Censorship is multiplying, not only at the media level but also against anyone who dares to express dissenting opinions against the government. Several prominent public figures have also been arrested:
For instance, opposition politician Ilya Yashin has been sentenced by the court to eight and a half years in prison for expressing his opposition to the invasion of Ukraine. The charges against him include “spreading false information meant to discredit the Russian army”, due to a series of posts in May about the murder and torture of Ukrainian civilians by Russian troops in the town of Bucha.
During the trial in early December, Yashin said: “I must remain in Russia, I must speak the truth loudly, and I must stop the bloodshed at any cost. It physically pains me to think how many people have been killed in this war, how many lives have been ruined, and how many families have lost their homes. You cannot be indifferent. And I swear I do not regret anything”. He added, “ it is better to spend 10 years behind bars as an honest man than quietly burn with shame over the blood spilled by your government”.
Russia has not only censored freedom of expression but has also demonstrated a repressive approach toward the freedoms of assembly and association.
- Freedom of Assembly:
Although all pandemic restrictions have been lifted, COVID-19 is still being used to this day as a pretext to ban public gatherings organized by political and civic activists. Organizers and participants are prosecuted for not respecting the rules, while authorities allow mass pro-government or state-sponsored events.
After the start of the war on February 24, 2022, for more than a month, protesters tried to express themselves by organizing protests against the invasion of Ukraine. As we have seen above in the article, the government’s response has been mass detention, police violence, and penalization of anti-war protests.
However, this did not prevent yet another wave in September 2022 after the announcement of the “mobilization for military reservists” decree. These events took place, particularly in the regions most affected by the mobilization, where ethnic minorities reside. It should be noted that ethnic minorities are among the largest number of military casualties.
Russia continues to exert a tenacious grip on the situation by afflicting a five-year prison sentence on anyone who repeatedly participates in unauthorized demonstrations.
An example would be the arrest of Vladim Khairullin in August 2022, which led to a one-year prison sentence for participating in a demonstration in support of political opposition leader Alexei Navalny, who was imprisoned. To this day, Vladim Khairullin remains in jail.
- Freedom of association:
In 2022, the Russian authorities established a blacklist of undesirable organizations and persecuted activists with alleged links to such organizations.
The General Prosecutor’s Office can designate as undesirable any foreign or international organizations that allegedly compromise Russian security, defense, or constitutional order. In this case, the organization must cease all activities in Russia.
Russian citizens who continue to be involved with them risk criminal penalties. It, therefore, becomes difficult for human rights defenders to operate within Russian territory. Relentlessly, Russia gradually cut off all means for these defenders to provide their protection.
In late December 2021, the Russian Supreme Court ordered the closure of the Memorial Association, which is the largest human rights organization in Russia. During the liquation process, both entities of Memorial, the International Memorial Society, and the Memorial Human Rights Center, were forced to close their doors.
In April 2022, the Russian authorities revoked the registration of 15 foreign non-governmental organizations and foundations, forcing them to shut down their offices in Russia. Among them are Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International.
Beyond the suppression of basic human rights, Russia has gone further in its barbarism.
Officially, it prohibits all use of torture since it is punished by law. Indeed, in July 2022, parliament adopted a law that explicitly introduces the notion of torture and applies an even stronger sentence than for previous cases that have been punished in the past, when the facts corresponded to the international definition of the word torture, including in a context of forced confessions (Torture Definition).
Moreover, Russia is one of the countries that ratified the United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman, or Degrading Treatment or Punishment on October 3, 1987. Consequently, Russia is supposed to be obligated to prevent and prohibit any use of torture and others, as well as investigate criminal cases when torture has been used.
Despite this, law enforcement officials have persisted in their use of torture.
TRIGGER WARNING: THE FOLLOWING EXAMPLE CAN BE MENTALLY HARMFUL TO SOME READERS
On September 26th, the police arrested, beat, and raped Artyom Kamardin for reciting anti-war poetry in public, online. Kamardin has been charged with “inciting hatred” over his verses critical of the Kremlin’s ongoing invasion of Ukraine. His lawyer, Leonid Solovyov, stated on September 27th, that his client had to be hospitalized for symptoms of concussion, bruises on his body, scratches on his face, and chest wounds, and remains in custody. The newspaper Novaya Gazeta also reported that the police severely beat Kamardin and raped him with a dumbbell (source).
The police also did not hide the fact that they forced Artem Kamardin to apologize in front of a camera and then shared the video on Kremlin-friendly social networks (source).
What is the international community doing to protect Russian civilians?
In October 2022, the UN Human Rights Council adopted a resolution establishing a surveillance mechanism for which reporters actively inform the situation in Russia. Based on proven facts, International organizations and human rights protection can act before the courts of international law.
And yesterday, these efforts borne fruit as on Friday, March 18th, 2023, the International Criminal Court (ICC), an international tribunal in the Hague that prosecutes individuals for international crimes such as genocide and war crimes, issued an arrest warrant against President Vladimir Putin and Maria Lvova-Belova, Russian children’s rights commissioner. The court holds President Putin individually responsible for the “unlawful deportation of the population (children) from occupied areas of Ukraine to the Russian Federation”. The court adds that the superior responsibility lies with Mr. Vladimir Putin, not with the civilians and Russian soldiers enrolled in the army, as they directly o to his authority. “There are reasonable grounds to believe that Mr. Putin bears individual criminal responsibility for the aforementioned crimes […] for his failure to exercise proper control over civilian and military subordinates who committed the acts or allowed for their commission, and who powerwasher his effective authority and control, under superior responsibility” (source).
The Kremlin spokesperson, Dmitry Peskov, has spoken out against the International Criminal Court (ICC), calling their inquiries “outrageous and unacceptable”. He noted that Russia, like many other countries, does not recognize the ICC’s jurisdiction and therefore considers any decisions made by them as null and void in the eyes of the law.
Meanwhile, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has called the ICC’s decision to investigate two Russian officials for war crimes an oric moment that will lead to accountability for their actions.
In practical terms, this means that if Putin travels to a country that recognizes the authority of the ICC, he will be immediately arrested. Even if the war in Ukraine comes to an end with Russia’s victory, the threat of this arrest warrant will continue to hang over his head. In other words, he is trapped. The gravity of this situation cannot be understated, as it represents a significant blow to Putin’s power and legacy. Despite his attempts to paint the ICC as a biased and illegitimate institution, the fact remains that his warrant serves as a stark reminder of the international community’s condemnation of Russia’s actions in Ukraine. The world is watching, and Putin’s every move will be scrutinized as he navigates this treacherous terrain.
Further sanctions have been imposed on Russia. In July 2022, a group of UN Human Rights experts condemned Russian authorities for repression of social groups, human rights defenders, and the media. They also urged the international community to redouble their efforts in supporting Russian civilians both inside and outside of Russia.
Now the following question remains, what will happen to the future of Russia? If Putin is not stopped, when will this bloodshed and violence come to an end? If Putin is ultimately arrested, who will be capable of governing the country in his place? Who will have sufficient authority over the elites and gain the people’s trust?



Comments