The fate of Armenian: between expansionist ambitions and international inactions
Updated: Mar 2, 2024
“Three thousand years of Armenian presence on Nagorno-Karabakh’s land were erased in only three days.” This is the declaration of Bruno Retailleau, senator and author of the resolution proposal “ Territorial Integrity of the Republic of Armenia". Since September 19, 2023, the conflict between the three following Caucasian country, Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijan and Armenia has intensified. An ethnic cleansing is ongoing according to some European Union’s institution which affirm this is even a genocide induced by hunger and coldness. The population mostly Armenian of the Nagorno-Karabakh endure a food and medicine shortage due to the blockade of the Lachin corridor by Azerbaijan since 2022.
On 2024 january 17th in the Senate, Mr. the senator Bruno Retailleau opened the debate. He is the author of the resolution proposed on the agenda, the Territorial Integrity of the Armenian Republic. The territorial integrity is not a trivial notion. It constitutes a principle of international right: an inalienable right of a sovereign state to preserve the integrity of its borders against any outside interference.
An historical reminder…
The conflict about the territorial integrity of Armenia historically started in 1980 when the Nagorno-Karabakh, a region mostly populated by Armenian in Azerbaijan, asked to be bind with the Armenian Republic. This request led to violences and the start of a geopolitical conflict which escalated during the military, cultural and territorial confrontations that occurred in the following decades.
After the soviet union collapsed in 1991, Azerbaijan and Armenia became independent. Legally speaking, the independence for countries in the soviet union was already practicable since the 1990 April 3rd Law. This law gives the opportunity for republics and autonomous regions to secede. Within the legal framework, the Republic of Artsakh in the Nagorno-Karabakh proclaimed its independence which was ratified by a referendum in 1991 December 10th. The borders of the Artsakh Republic were nonetheless not recognized by its international neighbors. However, the Nagorno-Karabakh region stayed a territory mostly populated by Armenian. Therefore, in 1994, when a ceasefire was negotiated to end the conflict, the region stayed de facto under the Armenian’s control. In other words, independent.
In 2020, hostilities regained strength. Azerbaijan violated its own ceasefire signature marking the escalation of the conflict. The country of sacred fire launched a military offensive to take the control back on what were their region, the Nagorno-Karabakh. According to them, it is about a violation of territorial integrity -as mentioned Philippe Folliot, senator for the central union. The Nagorno-Karabakh is not recognized as a state in its own right by other countries such as Russia or Turkey. Its independence is therefore not valid.
In November 2020, a new ceasefire agreement ended the confrontations. Russian peacekeeping forces have been deployed in the region. However, it didn’t stop Azerbaijan to attack Nagorno-Karabakh on September 19,2023. Nearly all the Artsakh Republic ran away. “What choices did they have between the luggage or the coffin?” rightly pointed out Valérie Boyer, senator for the Republicans in front of the Senate on January 17th.
Azerbaijan's territorial conquest project supported by Turkey
“Hardly anyone saw it coming”. Those are the words written by the New York Times after the tragedy last September. A pure hypocrisy for Valérie Boyer – senator for the Republicans. Armenians saw it coming a long time ago. It is the project planned by Azerbaijan, hand in hand with Turkey. Bruno Retailleau -author of the resolution – mentioned it in his speech under the name of “ Bakou’s project”. Bakou, the capital of Azerbaijan, applied an expansionist politic. Its purpose is to create a Neo-Ottoman area going from the Aegean Sea to the Caspian Sea. It would be a common area with Turkey, a way to continue their territorial sovereignty. Erdogan – president of Turkey – even qualified the two countries as one and only nation.
To accomplish its purpose, Azerbaijan undertook to block the Lachin corridor, the only point of contact between the Nagorno-Karabakh and the Republic of Armenia, which cross Azerbaijan’s lands. With no food, no fuel, no medicine, the humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh is getting worse since 2022. The flash offensive of September 19th 2023 was only the coup de grâce (final blow). This a genocide “induce by hunger and coldness” assert Valérie Boyer. Malnutrition is killing Armenians of the Nagorno-Karabakh since several months.
The Independence of Nagorno-Karabakh; a question yet unsolved
Since three thousand year of history, the Armenian population is living on the Nagorno-Karabakh’s land. In 1991, Armenians of this territory used their right of self-determination, right enshrined in the UN’s charter. This right of self-determination applies when populations break free from foreign domination. However, in the case of Nagorno-Karabakh, it is harder to accept this right since it has always been a region of Azerbaijan. Here, it is not about breaking free from foreign domination but independence ambitions based on the specificities distinguishing a population of a region from the national group to which it was previously linked. In this particular case, the use of the right of self-determination requires a democratic consultation. In 1991, it was the case. This Nagorno-Karabakh independence has been acquired thanks to a referendum on December 10 of the same year. But this is not enough.
The independence of a country also requires being recognized as an existing country on the international scene. However, until now, only three states recognized the Nagorno-Karabakh as an existing state: Abkhazia, South Ossetia-Alania and Transnistria. None of UN’s members recognized the country. We also had to wait 2020 for the French Senate to officially recognize Nagorno-Karabakh. The Senate wanted to use the independence of the country as a tool on a legal framework to instore peace.
What is surprising is that the Nagorno-Karabakh's population, mostly Armenian, was not recognized by Erevan – capital of the Armenian Republic. Yet, the recognition of its independence is the solution of this conflict. It is only in 2020 that Armenia judged “necessary a recognition process” of the Republic of Artsakh.
The inaction of European Union countries in the conflict
Today, the inaction of European union countries is a real issue. In addition to not granting an international recognition for Nagorno-Karabakh, countries of the European Union did not apply any punishment or even a beginning of punishment. To let Azerbaijan commit violation of war rights, Human rights, right of return for Armenian population, it is letting Azerbaijan believe that “it is possible to practice a blackmail diplomacy with no consequences”, declare Valérie Boyer at the Senate.
The European Union, because of its energetic dependence to Azerbaijan’s gas since the beginning of the Russo Ukrainian war, cannot allow itself to assert its authority in this part of the Caucasian region. The European Union is submitted to the will of Azerbaijan. Ursula Van Der Leyen, president of the European commission, has gone as far as sealing an agreement in Bakou -capital of Azerbaijan- regarding gas production and importation in European countries. This is a total disregard for the Armenian population. It seems that “no country can preserve peace anymore” deplore Pierre Jean Rochette, senator for the Independent. He states that “ the right of self-determination shall not become a pious wish. With less Russian gas, we are certainly more dependent of Azerbaijan gas. But this should not force us into silence nor inaction. We need to reinforce our energetic independence”.
Beyond the energetic dependence, countries like Italia, Spain but also Israël, Bulgaria, Slovakia and even Ukraine continue to supply Azerbaijan with weapons which they turn against Armenian. Azerbaijan also use this context to do negationist. The country does not recognized the Armenian genocide back in 1915 . It also affirms that Erevan – the capital of Armenia- was stolen by Armenians.
France, the only European country defending Armenian population
The purpose of the resolution at the senate is for France to carry the Armenian cause, regardless of geographical origins or partisan background. "We should not give in!" recalls Bruno Retailleau. The resolution must apply on every violation committed by Azerbaijan. On this day for instance, governors of Nagorno-Karabakh are still detain in Bakou’s jail. The Armenian culture and civilization are in danger. “We ask solemnly to the UNESCO to check on the state of Armenian's heritage”.
The Senator Stéphane Ravier adds “ while waiting to stop the gas agreements, we are asking to France and the international community to show its unconditional support to Armenia. We are also asking for the interruption of the adhesion process of Turkey to the European Union”. Armenia should be protected against threats it faces. Most importantly, Armenian should be allowed to return on their lands and preserve their inestimable cultural heritage.
The minister of Europe and foreign affairs, Stéphane Séjourné is the last to speak up in front of the Senate. He reminds France’s actions in this conflict. France brought an humanitarian support to Nagorno-Karabakh and the Armenian population. The French assistance tripled since the days following September 19th. 29 millions euros were provided with an emergency medical aid of 15 millions euros. This money was given to the CICR, the Armenian red cross, the UN and the emergency medical aid.
France also helped with the political response. The country was at the outpost on the international scene: it was the instigator of three UN security council meeting. The first being held on the day following the offensive of September. On October 5th, the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron showed its unfailing support to the independence and to the territorial integrity of the Armenian population. And most importantly, to the inviolability of Armenian borders.
France also reinforced its bilateral relations with the Republic of Armenia. Agreements were sealed for delivering military equipment. Armenia shall be able to protect its population and its territory. France also wish to reinforce its presence in the region by opening a consul agency and therefore to support infrastructures in transportations, energy and water. On an European scale, an awareness emerged : a plan to support Armenia will be establish by consensus.
A solution to this geopolitical issue…
Stéphane Séjourné close the session by affirming that “ a truthful and durable peace is only possible if internationals rights are respected. Such sovereignty and territorial integrity”. A ceasefire is not enough. The solution to this conflict still lies in the recognition of Nagorno-Karabakh’s independence. He concludes “ our actions continue and will amplify during the next months”. At the end of the session, the resolution passed with 336 voices for and one against on the 337 expressed voices.
© Senate


1 Comment